Jacob's my boyfriend, all semester long
Feels like a love song, sweet and strong
But I've been reckless, left and right
Kiss in the dark, snakes giving fright
Kissing booths, mascot on the run
Bonfire parties - totally no fun
Saucy texts to my kiss thief
If it's not Jacob, disbelief
Wait, what if I've got it super wrong?
What if it hasn't been Jacob all along?
He cuts me off, time to prove
Icing swipe before I move
Icing on my face
Is the icing on the cake
Laughing with frosting all over the place
If this is love then I like the taste
Icing on my face
Is the icing on the cake
I pull away, grab my phone
Type it out for his headstone
"I've got a boyfriend now, it's true
So please stop texting. Thank you"
Hit send fast, don't overthink
Watch the little message blink
But deep down I have belief
Jacob was always my kiss thief
Time to kiss without disguise
No more mystery, no surprise
Icing on my face
Is the icing on the cake
Laughing with frosting all over the place
If this is love then I like the taste
Icing on my face
Is the icing on the cake
"You've got something right there," he grins
Points to my face, I wipe my chin
"Wrong spot. Here, let me"
His hand lingers, steady
"You're so beautiful," he swears
"Even with icing everywhere"
Wait, I thought he got it?
He dabs my nose and commits
"You missed a spot." Oh please, come on
He's icing my face like I'm in chiffon
"Oh, it's so on," I grab the bowl
Frosting flying, zero control
He catches my wrist, spins me round
Pins me back, I'm spellbound
"You really are bite-sized," he teases low
Kitchen island, sugar glow
I meet his stare, it feels so right
"Then maybe you should bite"
Icing on my face
Is the icing on the cake
Kissing with frosting all over the place
It's good, but an unfamiliar pace
Icing on my face
Is the icing on the cake
Phone buzzes loud in my jeans
I already know what that means
I pull back slow, frosting smeared
Butterflies turn into fear
The kiss felt off, just slightly wrong
Turns out this isn't our love song
Jacob's not my kiss thief
Good grief