All the Way In

Why the fuck did you ever say hi

And why did I have to reply?

I was in love, I was in love

With your best friend, who stayed out of my way

We were at a party for his birthday one Saturday

You shook my hand from the hot tub

Then realized we'd already met

I teased you, like "How could you forget?"

Boyfriend jeans rolled up to my knees

Soaking my legs and cold feet

Unwilling to go all the way in

All the way

All the way

All the way in

All the way

All the way

All the way in

And that's how it was when you wanted to fuck

And I was like "Hey, can we just

Take it slow?" Take it slow

You were someone I wanted to know

A little bit better

Before letting you all the way in

All the way

All the way

All the way in

All the way

All the way

All the way in

I'm done playing lifeguard from a lonely wooden tower

I'm done diving deep, my lungs don't have the power

To save another drowning man who's forgotten how to swim

And now we're both scared to go all the way in

All the way

All the way

All the way in

All the way

All the way

All the way in