We've got the same music taste
We both score the top-notch grades
We've even got the same friends
And equally we love them
You know what else is similar?
Apart from our star signs and our favourite shows
There's this guy we both know
What you don't know
Is I also love him
But I gotta lock that secret deep within
'Cause you automatically win
Oh Evelyn
Girl can't you see
We're almost like the same thing
Different birthdays still similarly tripping over a boy
But he always likes Evelyn more
You've got this blue doe-eye gaze
And your soft hair gives you an angelic grace
That's the type of girl he's looking for
Seems like what everyone's been looking for
You know what else's got me suffering
Apart from the fact our friends are calling the wedding
Is how I can't help being just as good a friend to you
So I used the plans I made only to make your dream come true
But I gotta shove the tears back in my eyes
'Cause you always get what I desire
Oh Evelyn
Girl can't you see what you're unintentionally stealing
A chance with the love of my life
Even if he liked me before
When Evelyn walks in through the door
They always like Evelyn more
Ever since your birth
Visions from heaven were sung
Ethereal promises
Leaving me to be the friend of the pretty one
You always get a chance at what I want
Never leaving any scraps for anyone
And it hurts most how you're not horrible at all
How can I curse someone who isn't even flawed
Oh Evelyn
Girl can't you see we're almost like the same thing
Different birthdays still similarly tripping over a boy
But he always liked Evelyn more
Oh Evelyn
Girl can't you see what you're unintentionally stealing
A chance with the love of my life
Even if he liked me before
When Evelyn walks in through the door
They always like Evelyn more